Cardamom I always associate with chai - that’s extremely easy to get around here. Walmart carries it, and the average Kroger in town as well.
Mace…I had to go looking for that, but not very far - the gourmet shop about 40 minutes away. It was a bit expensive, though, something like $12 for a little jar, and I’ve used it maybe twice in two years - once in a hot bev (I think) and once in a meat pie. If you want something that tastes right out of 15th century England…mace is your ticket.
Star anise I just bought for the first time not long ago, for a challenge. I haven’t used it since. I think I used it in a drink. I had to go to the international market to find it, though.
Yeah, Sharonville is a Cincy suburb. There is a knot of Indian markets (food, clothes, etc) through there, and some restaurants as well.
Risotto - I made it once and it was gummy, so I just assumed I messed it up.
I do love rice pudding, though. It’s just about the only rice dish I can make with any level of consistently good results. Me and rice don’t get along in the kitchen very well.