I suppose for those who celebrate Christmas, they do what works for them, but that would raise my eyebrow a little.
My wife’s family, they exchange lists of what they want, and then everyone buys off the lists. When we had our first Christmas together (keep in mind, I come from a family that doesn’t celebrate Christmas), I was surprised by that, because it seemed like cheating to me.
After that, I told MrsT to not give me a list and to not expect one from me (though I did provide one to her parents because you’ve got to respect the elders), that gift-giving, you need to know the recipient and pick something out for them.
That’s why, when we were all exchanging gifts over the years (we no longer do…too many people to buy for these days), I became something of a family legend, and when we’d moved to drawing names of people to buy for, everyone wanted me to pick their name, because they knew it would be a good gift, tailored to them, and a surprise.
This year, though, I really came up short for MrsT. It’s been a year of distractions, to say the least.
If you never celebrated Christmas as a kid, then you probably never wrote a letter to Santa, or sat on a mall Santa's knee. We wrote to Santa as young children, and that's how my parent's knew what we wanted. As older children, we just went straight to Santa, AKA mom and dad, with our wishlist.
I don't see having a gift wish list as cheating, especially with adults. Once I went off to college, and never lived with my parents again, they had no way of knowing what to get me unless I told them some things I wanted.
Then there was buying for my dad. He never wanted anything he couldn't just go an buy for himself. Asking him what he wanted for Christmas or his birthday was pointless. You wouldn't get an answer. If he wanted something, he went out and bought it. My strategy for the last 30-plus years has been to buy him something fun. When my dad retired, I had to teach him how to play, because all he knew was how to work. That played into my gift-giving strategy perfectly. I would get something that he would never buy for himself, because it was not something "practical." My goal was to get him something he didn't know he wanted, that he would end up happily using or playing with.
CD