Lullabelle
Midlands, England
Our family is huge. Gift giving became a burden. For years the siblings drew names and gifted the nieces and nephew. Now the Nieces and their Spouses have asked to be included in the name drawing. A gift in the range of $50 for your secret recipient. We do small gifts, maybe ornaments from Hobby Lobby at 50% off or, in my case, food - brownies or cookies or mini holiday bread loaves. We spoil the great nieces and nephews outrageously. They get sooo much STUFF. I give them money. My youngest Niece and my eldest Great Nephew are 16. I give them money to use at their discretion. The younger Great Nieces and Nephews are given money for their education account. My eldest Great Niece is 9 so she may get money to spend at her discretion. The things these children like or want are all tech stuff that is beyond my budget.
Once all the nieces and nephews arrived and it was obvious the childbearing was over, my wife's family moved to that model, but it lasted just a few years.
One family member kind of put herself in charge of the whole thing, and began changing the rules and dictating terms, then other family members decided to buck that, and it just sort of fell apart.
I can't remember exactly, but I think someone wanted to move to a "just buy gifts for the 'kids'," even though the "kids" were 25-35 years old, and someone else (quite likely me) ended up balking at that. It wasn't that I wanted a gift for myself, but I do get a little churlish when someone tells me Christmas is "mainly just for the kids," so it's very possible I was the one who finally excused himself, causing the whole pyramid to crumble, but I'm not exactly sure. Sounds like me, though.
TVC's family is rather large so the agreement is we buy for his 3 brothers and his eldest brother's 4 grown up kids (usually wine or chocolate), they buy for us (again wine or chocolate). That is where it stops with agreement all around. There are just far too many to go further.
My family is quite small, dad gets gifts, my brother's 2 girls get money, his son gets toys as he is under 10, my brother always used to get a gift from us.